Sunday, September 8, 2019

Loyal Follower, Treasonous Faith


Icon by Kelly Lattimore, “The Good Shepherd”


Watch the Video of This Sermon Given at All Saints Church of Christ: 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJdxa6Ne8aw


Luke 14:25-33

Now large crowds were traveling with Jesus; and he turned and said to them, "Whoever comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple. Whoever does not carry the cross and follow me cannot be my disciple. For which of you, intending to build a tower, does not first sit down and estimate the cost, to see whether he has enough to complete it? Otherwise, when he has laid a foundation and is not able to finish, all who see it will begin to ridicule him, saying, `This fellow began to build and was not able to finish.' Or what king, going out to wage war against another king, will not sit down first and consider whether he is able with ten thousand to oppose the one who comes against him with twenty thousand? If he cannot, then, while the other is still far away, he sends a delegation and asks for the terms of peace. So therefore, none of you can become my disciple if you do not give up all your possessions."

Well, that escalated. 

I just love the voice of Jesus in Scripture. I am always comforted to know that he does not shy away from conflict and see him use words that aren’t always sweet, but often salty. Because God knows I tend to prefer salty over sweet, and it just feels good to see that same preference in Christ every once in a while. 

I’m trying to imagine this interaction. Were the large crowds with Jesus just talking amongst themselves as he turned to them? Did this call to hate family and carry crosses come out of nowhere?

What, exactly, would make the God of Rhetoric stop what he was doing to call attention to this group? What conversations prompted this holy hyperbole to a group of already dedicated followers? They were traveling with him after all, they were presumably already convinced. And any other religious leader would have been happy with that. It’s weird that Jesus is trying to thin his crowd. No, don’t just follow me. HATE your family. Your children. Your life.

He goes on, questioning their commitment. “Are you even thinking about this? Are you even powerful enough to do this?” I don’t want to project anything on this text, but I almost hear his slightly sarcastic tone, and I’ve got to wonder, “Why?” Who are these crowds that Jesus is working to convince that this journey is too difficult for them, that the cross is too heavy. And since when did hate come into this equation?

I find it helpful to take this passage out for a while and let it breathe. It sits smack dab in the middle of Luke and if ingested verse by verse, way too quickly, I’m afraid we might get too inebriated to figure out what exactly Jesus is saying and to who. So, let’s give it a moment while we look at what’s happening in the larger context of the story Luke tells. 

Each biblical author (or community of authors) weaves commentary throughout the narrative itself. Luke, in particular, focuses on telling of a King Jesus. From birth story to death story, Jesus is presented as an alternative to the current government and powers that be. It is a political story. A story about economics and loyalty where at each turn, Jesus calls people to follow him into His empire—the one that flips the script on power and authority, that privileges the least of these, and one that flies in the face of allegiance to Rome, to the Synagogue Leaders and Gatekeepers, and the wealthy and exploitative class. 

And I think this is why we see Luke constantly present Jesus as a foil to the rich and powerful. Wealth and power are constantly challenged, in parables and in real life. The story of the Rich Ruler. Of the Prodigal Son. Of the Good Samaritan. All these address wealth, power, and even loyalty. Even the story of the crucifixion, as women are weeping and wailing for Jesus, Luke reports that Jesus quotes Hosea 10, and in doing so, condemns the earthly kingdom, the political authorities, and religiously powerful, all while inviting the sinner—the “least of these”—into his own kingdom. For someone who many Christians today deny ever “getting political”, Jesus sure uses a lot of political language. King of the Jews—and all of people. 

So when we see Luke tell any story about Jesus, we have to keep this in mind. Who is Jesus talking to? And why?

Hate your family. Carry the cross. Lose your life. And then he says this, “Which of you, intending to build a tower, doesn’t sit down to estimate it? What king would not consider it first?  Therefore, none of you can be my disciples unless you give up all of your possessions.” 

Now, we know a few things: these people had the power to build towers. The analogy of being a king landed with them. They had possessions to give up. These large crowds had to have been privileged people. People with economic and familial security. And Jesus is telling them to give it all up and to pledge loyalty to him. Loyalty to the death. 

I’m going to go out on a limb to say that this isn’t just about wealth. Jesus himself benefited from patronage—although even in that he turned on its head, using the money and support from women, who were some of the least privileged and powerful at the time. 

If Luke is presenting an alternative empire through Jesus, then these words must be challenging something more than just economic standing. He must be challenging privilege. Because what is costlier than laying down one’s privilege, one’s security, and one’s power to take up a cross that leads to certain death? 

A point of clarification is required. I have seen my share of sermons and platitudes misuse Jesus’s words to heap guilt upon the poor and those marginalized by society. “Don’t complain. The cost of following Jesus means you aren’t going to be rich. Just be ok with your suffering.” 

But Jesus is not speaking to the poor or the powerless or the disadvantaged.

It’s generational wealth and privilege and security that are being challenged—not those in trauma or crisis or who are unsafe. 

Here he’s renouncing family ties for the well-connected—not the disconnected. 

To one group he describes a cross too heavy to bear, but to another, he says “I will give you rest.” What separates those two groups? Privilege. 

And the only bootstraps that are in this conversation are those of the rich. The ones of the poor are being washed. 

But today, while I think economic disparity can be a conversation that’s helpful and important in its own right, there’s another parallel to be made. Religious conversations today about security and safety and protection seem to revolve less and less around dying for Jesus and counting the cost, and more and more around protecting one’s family for Jesus. From guns to walls to bringing back prayer to schools and increasing policing and prisons and fighting wars on drugs and nations and news, safety, protection, fear become the driving factors of so many Christians’ behavior. And it’s not just these things, lest we “other” a particular group. Safety, protection, and fear seem to drive all of our behaviors—especially for those of us that hold multiple privileges and powers. From gentrification to private schooling to “peacemaking” that looks more like “status-quo keeping” and “just wait and be patient and calm down” that looks more like “be complicit in your own oppression.” And we don’t like these things pointed out either. It threatens our sense of security. 

The cost we are counting is whether or not we will give up our privilege and safety in order to follow Jesus into his alternative empire. Where do our loyalties lie? Protecting our family and our security and ourselves—or dying to serve the sinners and oppressed and sick and poor and defeated.

What does it mean, then, to be a loyal follower of Jesus? To, for lack of a better analogy, pledge allegiance to a different flag? A flag of peace and sacrifice and death and treating people better than we treat ourselves?

We know from his life it’s not to be fearless. This is a holy man, son of Parent God, who trembles in a garden alone, begging for mercy, sweating from the fear of his body being broken, bruised, bloodied, and destroyed by the empire. This faith—this treasonous faith that put God above country, above law, above past allegiances, above family, above wealth, above status—resulted in death. He knew all of this, he was scared of this, and still had the audacity to ask others to join him. 

And I think those who did. The ones who didn’t really have the capital to spare in the first place. The ones who didn’t have the power or money or status. Not really. 

Only two swords between them. 

Women funding them, but lacking social power. Women with sexual trauma, men with radical ideas of overthrowing government, children, the disabled, the poor, those in prison. They were the ones who followed Jesus to the ends of the cross. 

And those who didn’t? The ones with the money and power and authority? The large crowds that Jesus turned to and said, “Count the cost. Die. Give up your possessions. Your safety. Your security.” Yes, they followed Jesus to the ends of the cross, too, and then they hung him on it. He said to give up everything and they said, sure, but not this. 

And today we have to make the same choice. What will we give up? Who will we pledge loyalty to? 

I call this a treasonous faith because it betrays the power of this world, of this country, of our leaders, of our privilege and comfort, and invites us into a holy mutiny, where we speak peace, free captives, feed the hungry, invite the immigrant, love the addicted, house the unhoused, accommodate the disabled, clothe the unclothed, connect the disconnected, and stand against the powers that falsely promise safety. It invites us into death, but promises us resurrection. 

And it’s ok if you’re scared. I am too. But this is The Way—the only way—to follow Jesus.

Friday, July 5, 2019

Raze the Roof (And the Rest of the House)

I want to address a critique I get often in my DM's and on some of my public posts about the church, racism, sexism, and violence against women. 
I can think of a few posts recently where people have said that my language is divisive, bitter, or unproductive. This usually doesn't bother me--I've been unfriended and blocked since the beginning of my deconstruction journey. But it is interesting to hear these calls of peace from people contributing to the problem. It often puts me to mind of the passage in Jeremiah (6:13-14) where God is offering a warning to Jerusalem:
"From the least to the greatest,all are greedy for gain;prophets and priests alike,all practice deceit.They dress the wound of my peopleas though it were not serious.‘Peace, peace,’ they say,when there is no peace."
For the longest time, Jeremiah has been my go-to for lament, frustration, deconstruction, and validating my experiences in the church. While so many cry "Peace, Peace" through calls not to be embittered or divisive or unloving, they fail to understand the severity of the wounds of those around them. 
We are surrounded by people bleeding out from the wounds inflicted by their faith systems, and yet, so many observers wish to pass over the hurt and focus on the "positive." 
Hard truth: For many, there is no positive. 
Another hard truth: For many, it is unfathomable to return to these faith systems. 
The hardest truth: Your whitewashed tombs are not attractive to those on the outside. 
Let people lament. Let people deconstruct. Let people tear it all down and start over. 
When the foundation is cracked, the whole thing needs to be razed. Don't stop people from creating safer, stronger spaces.

Thursday, June 27, 2019

The Women's Issue: How Progressive CoC Men Continue to Do Us Harm

Clip art of four women or female presenting people with backs turned and arms around each other, next to picture of a microphone, and clip art of five hipster looking men facing the camera, underneath are the words: The Women's Issue: how progressive cox men continue to do us harm.

No matter how hard I try to veer away from it, I find myself constantly coming back to the “gender” discussion as it relates to the Stone Campbell Movement (i.e. the Churches of Christ). My passion for this topic is born out of necessity and identity. As long as I have some ties to the Church of Christ, I am going to see this fight as my own. As long as I am a woman, I am going to see this fight as my own. And as long as I am someone mourning a calling that was never fulfilled, I am going to see this fight as my own. 

The further and further I grow away from the faith of my youth, the more urgency I feel at conveying this message. Honestly, the more relationships I build with women leaving Christianity in droves, survivors of violence, queer women, black women, women of color, disabled women, young and old women, I find my insides bubbling with an anxiety to tell ALL THE PEOPLE of the harm complementarian and misogynistic theology perpetrates. 

A while back ago, on my other blog, I wrote a series discussing the verses and exegesis needed to come to support a “broadening” of women’s roles in the church and encourage mutuality and egalitarianism. There are blogs and books and journal articles and several voices that can contribute to that discussion. I’m grateful for them, because in 2014, that’s exactly what I needed to read and hear. But the 2019 me is a little less tolerant of that discussion. It could be that 5 years after seeing the discussion and progress in my church tradition stall, I have become disenchanted. More likely it’s 5 years of constant interactions with conservative AND progressive men in which this conversation is still intellectualized and women are still being harmed. It’s 5 years of experiences and stories and relationships that have propelled me to a place where I am fed up with tip toeing around things that should be easy and simple—treat people equally and with respect. This is Kindergarten level stuff that is still being debated. And I’m through. 

So, this post is not going to be exegetical in nature, nor pulling from Scripture or any other Holy text, or even appealing to Greek or Hebrew. Go to the library or your nearest friendly neighborhood theologian and explore the complexities of culture and language and the Bible and do some digging into your belief system. If you aren’t willing to do that, then my comments aren’t going to sway you anyway. 

In fact, the only time I’m ever going to mention Greek is when I tell you to stop using Greek to prove whether or not I can exist as myself in a space. When you use Greek to gatekeep, you’ve really sunk to a weird place. Quit trying to make it happen. Or, as I say…

Text of a bad pun which says Kephale this misogyny away from me

This post, instead, is for the men who are interested in understanding how to talk about gender justice in a way that honors women, improves their own allyship, or are just curious to why “letting women pray or preach” doesn’t cut it anymore. For the people in the back, please take out your earbuds, straighten up, and pay attention: Gender justice is not a “close enough” kind of sport. I’m going to explain a little why this requires your full participation and commitment.

Also, as a note, I can only speak to all this as a white, cis-het woman. That’s my social location and context. When I address gender justice in the CoC, I am doing so as a white woman commenting on white-majority churches. Knowing this is understanding that what I say may not completely make sense in other contexts, with other marginalized groups. But here’s the thing about marginalization. The more identities you hold, the more likely you are to experience everything I’m about to say 100x worse and in more traumatic ways. Which should grieve us all deeply. 

In the past, I’ve caveat’ed and tiptoed around this, holding hands as much as I could to people reading, hoping and praying they would feel led by my words. While I still truly believe in the power of words, I think these conversations best happen in relationship. So while I’ll welcome anyone to this space who believes women are meant to, as I saw in a CoC Facebook group just moments ago, “stay at their post” rather than be consumed by feminism, I recognize that sweetening and disguising my words will never be what helps you understand the harm your theology is causing. It’s going to be other men that do that. 

So, other men. Let’s go. 

Someone asked me the other day how men who are trying to do this work can be better allies to women. I appreciated the question, mainly because many of the men I meet who call themselves allies believe they deserve accolades just for showing up. But this is a dangerous place to be because instead of actually helping women, it stalls the movement and puts us in harm’s way. 

How? 

Two women with arms raised and a conversation bubble saying "Join us." Above them are five men behind a pulpit saying, "We're good."



When you say you are an ally or express to a woman that you are working towards mutuality or egalitarianism or gender justice, you have created a point of trust between her and you. She is rightly expecting that in situations where men or women are calling into question her ability to lead or treating her as a subordinate or harassing/abusing her, you will intervene. NOT as a savior, but as someone who is going to call out the behavior and be by her side to pick up the pieces. This is especially true if you have any kind of influence, power, or privilege in the spaces in which she participates. If you are a preacher or deacon or elder or professor or influential blogger or speaker or podcaster (you get the idea), she will assume that you will use your platform to affirm her, align with justice, and act against the systems that subordinated her in the first place. 


Just reading the above paragraph, however, it becomes fairly clear that the allyship claimed by men in the CoC and what is actually happening are distant cousins at best. I think this is because there have been a few misconceptions about gender justice, as well as some major missteps men have taken on the path to opening up “roles” to women in the church. Now it’s time to step into the “Ouch, Oops” territory and figure out what clean-up looks like.

Misconception

Gender justice and gender roles are often discussed interchangeably, but are two very different things. To be anti-sexist and anti-misogynist, it takes a lot more work than just allowing women in the pulpit. In fact, "letting" women preach is an action that may flow from a commitment to gender justice, but definitely can be an action devoid of justice. 


For example, an "egalitarian church" that opens up their pulpit/eldership to women can also be one that ignores violence against women, participates in defined gender roles ("men are like this, women are like this"), and generally treats women like second-class citizens. (I have had direct experience with men and churches like this. My friends have had direct experiences with men and churches like this. Remember when I said women are being put in harm’s way? This trauma lasts a long time and doesn’t go away with time.) 


We typically don't do a great job at making these distinctions, and as such, all these conversations become what women are "allowed" to do, rather than valuing women as human beings deserving of the same rights, respect, and attitudes as men. (This right here is not only the gold standard, but NECESSARY for women to know, feel, and live into as they participate in faith communities.) 



What happens is that all these discussions are grounded in "roles" or "what can women do" rather than "how do we conceptualize gender and treat women." This last part is really what makes or breaks an ally—I could say a prayer or teach a class of men, but if I am still seen as subordinate or the people I’m teaching are teaching my daughter things like purity culture or the preacher is beating his wife or the elder is coming on to the teenage girl—that space is not safe and those men are not allies. They are dangerous.



Misstep 

We tend to frame all these discussions around "allowance/freedom" rather than "justice/wholeness." God's intended kingdom looks inclusive. So instead of saying, "Well, we now live in the freedom of allowing women to serve," we should be saying, "We have the command to make our spaces just for all." 

Instead, what happens is what I see in so many comment threads about women's roles: 

comic strip describing two men having a discussion about women. First man says, "here are verses that support my belief women can't lead men, insert Timothy and genesis and corinthians." Second man says, "let's talk about exegesis and background and culture." First man says, "slippery slope, conservative view of the Bible, literalist." Second man responds, "We need to move towards grace and freedom." First man (who is red in the face) says " are you telling me what to do? I'm not a bad person! I just have a different opinion." Second man, now almost invisible in the picture, says "I'm not saying your opinion is wrong. Just let us live in our freedom, with our interpretation, and we'll let you live in yours." Above both men are pictures of women crossing their arms.

I understand everyone's inclination towards peace, and what I often hear (especially from the autonomous, yet progressive crowd) is that we can't police people's behaviors. I agree. But I am surprised (no I’m not) that these discussions always seem to end with men telling other men, "let's agree to disagree."

As a woman, what that says to me is that my trauma from this very dangerous and devastating theology is less important than the relationship between these two men. The kicker, is that often this relationship is only one built around social structure. Preachers allowing other preachers to say these things in order “not to rock the boat” so they can speak at the next lectureship. Men writing for complementarian publications and appearing on podcasts with their “dudes” and letting these comments slide. 

I have seen so many male "allies" back down or go radio silent when pushed on the question, "Are you saying I'm wrong about this?"

Here’s the deal. 

The answer to that question should always be a resounding and absolute "YES. Yes, you are wrong. Your theology is wrong. It is harmful. We can stay friends but I am very much in disagreement with you on this and I think it is sinful."

Progressive CoC men who call yourselves allies? You need to be like Jeremiah in the dirty pit shouting to these men that their theology is poop. 

Yes. 

I said poop. 

Misstep

Men who study the Bible (whether professionally, academically, or just as a hobby) tend to intellectualize these discussions—especially online. 


Comment threads and blog posts and tweets devolve into a match about who studied the most verses or knows the best Greek or is the most well-read. 


First, it is TOXIC for women to continue to watch these interactions. It feels as if we are "issues" or "philosophies" rather than living, breathing, human beings. It is exhausting because we have heard it all before and honestly, I don't care one iota whether the Greek word for "head" means source or authority. I care whether I'm seen and treated as an equal. Whether I experience harm or violence. 


Second, these conversations should ALWAYS point back to the women being discussed. I'm all about alleviating the burden of women always having to jump in, but true allies are the ones quoting women, directing people to women's writings and talks, and constantly reframing the discussion to talk about justice. (And backing women up when they do jump into the discussion. A rarely used, but wonderful phrase, is “She already said that.”)

Yellow graphic with pink writing that says "she already said that". Clipart next to words of five women looking at the reader.

While I don’t believe it is on the person being harmed to walk people through how not to harm (take responsibility, guys, and do some deep learning), I do find it helpful to frame these discussions around steps people can take to do better. If anything, the education is here. You have to decide what it is worth to take or leave (and understand the impact that will have on the women around you). 


How to Ally Better

So, in a perfect world, all these conversations around gender justice and women's roles in the church would be full of male allies calling out the misogyny of their friends and fellow ministers. 

Gendered jokes, stereotypes, excuses, and even discussing rape allegations using terms like "credible" or "not credible" are all things that need to stop. And women can't be the only ones saying they are wrong. 

One of the things I have witnessed are calls to peace from people who have no skin in the game, so to speak. Responding to women by tone policing or telling them to "be peaceful", "calm down" or "realize these are good guys, trying their hardest," means nothing in the face of violence. 

Men need to amp it up so women don't have to. 

And here's where it all culminates:

Any form of telling or showing a woman she is a second-class citizen is sinful. Full stop. That absolutely needs to be called out, and women just do not have the social capital in our tradition to do that. (We still do it. All the time. But every time we do it, it costs us something. And that something is usually a piece of our dignity, souls, or faith.)

Here's the deal. 

I completely understand the complication of being reliant on income and a job. People who protest are typically not allowed access to the systems they are protesting, and people with access to those systems are typically kicked out if they start to protest. Having influence to change people's minds slowly and infiltrating the system through targeted conversations and moving strategically has often been the gold standard among progressive CoC men. 

Almost too gold of a standard. 

It seems as if all y'all are doing it. 

We've got to have some protestors, guys, or eventually, you'll all look around and not only lose women to your congregations, but to faith altogether. I've got the receipts. It's already happening. 

I don't expect all men or male leaders to say, "Do this right, or I'm leaving." 

But I do expect subversion. 

And respect. 

And showing allyship in safe spaces (like secret social media groups). 

And participating in actions that won't cost as much (like refusing to appear on a podcast or speak at a lectureship or write for a publication if those things contribute to misogynistic, patriarchal, or sexist practices). 

At the end of the day, there must be the realization that anything less than full justice is not good enough. It's not. It's not ok to say, "Well, the women can do everything BUT a, b, and c," or "We're having these discussions, and that's a big step," or "It doesn't happen automatically and we're making some progress."

Maybe you just can't get there. Maybe your church community can't make the leap and you can't afford to leave and you can't afford to speak out. Lament about that, but don't fool yourself into thinking it's fine to give women a "little" bit and that's fine. 

It's not.

It's still harmful.

Fess up to that. If you can't change it, fess up to how horribly crappy that is and support women who need to leave those systems. 

Because eventually, we will need to leave those systems. If they don't kill us first.


Quote from Dorothy Sayers that says the following: “Perhaps it is no wonder that the women were first at the Cradle and last at the Cross. They had never known a man like this Man - there never has been such another. A prophet and teacher who never nagged at them, never flattered or coaxed or patronised; who never made arch jokes about them, never treated them either as "The women, God help us!" or "The ladies, God bless them!"; who rebuked without querulousness and praised without condescension; who took their questions and arguments seriously; who never mapped out their sphere for them, never urged them to be feminine or jeered at them for being female; who had no axe to grind and no uneasy male dignity to defend; who took them as he found them and was completely unself-conscious. There is no act, no sermon, no parable in the whole Gospel that borrows its pungency from female perversity; nobody could possibly guess from the words and deeds of Jesus that there was anything "funny" about woman's nature.”

Wednesday, May 29, 2019

I Bet You Think This Song Is About You

Some unformed thoughts about white, progressive church-y men and their language around women, sexuality, and LGBT+ identities. 

I recently listened to a popular CoC podcast (message me for link) that really solidified my feelings on this trending progressive preacher movement within the white-led Churches of Christ.

We come from a movement in which traditionalism is so rigid that any kind of freedom or grace practiced appears liberal and progressive. Because guitars are often seen as sinful and women praying or passing metal trays are seen as deceived by Satan, making any kind progress on these fronts automatically puts that CoC in the progressive camp. 

But there is a real danger to this kind of classification system. Having instruments and letting women pray does not equate egalitarianism or justice or anti-racism or anti-sexism work (which one typically correlates with progressive-ism). In fact, these things are great tricks for churches to feel like they've embraced a more justice-centered faith, without requiring them to do any justice work. 

As such, more and more voices are being heralded as leaders of the progressive Church of Christ and saviors of the Restoration Movement--but those voices are overwhelmingly white and male. Because these leaders have been thrust into the spotlight for their differing worship practices and beliefs (i.e. allowing guitars and letting women use a microphone), they often are called on to be the de facto experts on all things gender, race, and justice. 

They are overwhelmingly speaking at progressive church conferences and writing articles for Wineskins and hosting podcasts and writing books and lending their voices to a movement that *should* be led by women, the disabled, and people of color. 

Allowing a woman to preach does not mean you are anti-sexist or consciously working against patriarchal systems. 

Playing a guitar does not mean your church is inclusive to LGBT+ folks. 

Running an inner city ministry does not make you an expert on anti-racism, nor does it absolve you of your complicity in white supremacy. 

Are women tokens or are their voices informing every conversation you have and host about women? (Also, why are you hosting and having conversations about women without women at least being at the table?) 

This statement goes for every marginalized identity you can think of. 

The Church of Christ has a LONG way to go with justice work. And progressive ministers (however defined) need to examine their desires to lead these conversations, step aside, and allow those they glibly discuss to take the lead.

Thursday, May 9, 2019

#becauseofRHE

A grief like this
makes
the world feel
Empty
Meaningless 
Hostile.
Jesus literally wept.
Even though resurrection was coming.
Because
Hope doesn’t always assuage grief. 
The cold doesn’t always go away,
Even when friends are packed in next to the tomb. 
Even though resurrection was coming,
Jesus’s tears dropped into cold pools of grief. 
And in the moment,
Even he knew,
Grief comes before hope. 
And a hope rushed is not hope,
But a way people refuse to be baptized in tears of God. 
God. 
God.
God.
Oh my God.
colorful illustration of author Rachel held Evans

Wednesday, May 8, 2019

Let’s Have The Talk

Illustration of baby in uterus with flowers at feet
Illustration by Language of Birth
Friends,

It’s time to have the abortion talk. I’ve been vague in past posts for a few reasons:

1. Discussing something as gray as abortion often devolves into un-winnable black-and-white arguments. When people believe abortion is murder, and not only murder, but murder of a being that has the same soul and development and functioning as a live baby, there’s an uncrossable chasm of value-systems and belief. There’s nowhere to go.

2. Many people can’t have this conversation without name-calling. Or showing gruesome pictures or linking to articles full of rhetoric and devoid of science. And typically, people become apoplectic. It’s hard to discuss this without anger.

3. Not many minds will be changed over social media. (As much as I post, there *are* reasons for things I post. And I am very intentional in how I say them and what audience I’m talking to.)

But even with all these reasons, I’m going to wade into this conversation. It is high time to add my voice—not because I think my voice is more important than others, but because, as a woman, I must speak for my sisters (born and unborn).

A few rules if you’re going to comment:

**No name calling, unsolicited link posting, picture posting, or memes.

**Be considerate and kind. Recognize these two things: (1) some people who are reading most likely have had abortions, (2) no one in this discussion wants to kill babies (and if you believe that, I need you to step away from the 24-hour news cycle and your pastor’s Twitter feed, and really meet some people who have lived different lives than you).

**No reference to liberals or conservatives. Let’s talk as people imbibed with love and compassion.

**Hello, men! While I really appreciate you wanting to be a voice for the voiceless (hope to see you practicing that for all of humanity, not just the unborn), it is super inappropriate to speak over women in this thread. Until science makes it possible to implant a fetus in your body and carry it for 9 months and take drugs and have major surgery/push that fetus out through an opening the size of a grape, we can talk. But until then, the women get preference. Comment if you want, but this is your warning. Talking over women gets you muted and deleted.

**My last rule is I can add rules as I see fit. My page, my thoughts, my game.

So if I’ve kept people this far, let’s get started.

The article I’m referencing is here.

Slate is notorious for posting biased things, but the law is clear. (You can look it up!) The heartbeat bill (which has also been passed in four states this year alone) has many implications—most of them devastating for the most marginalized of women.

So Georgia (which, by the way, has some of the highest rates of maternal mortality in the country) has decided not only to ban abortions after 6 weeks, but potentially imprisoning (and killing) those who perform or have them illegally.

While I could talk about America’s incarceration rates (and the outrageous bias against black and indigenous people in the criminal justice system) or the absolute absurdity of murdering someone to punish them for “murder” (put in quotes, as I’ll explain below), that’s more than I can do in this post. That’s in the weeds. Let’s stay high level.

First, there is an exception for rape and incest and medical emergencies. Yet, if politicians and pundits and religious folk *really* thought abortion was murder, why would it matter if a pregnancy occurred because of bad circumstances? It’s still a life. So already, we see many of the staunchest anti-abortion advocates making concessions out of compassion. Which leads me to think that, for them, there’s something else at play than just thinking of abortion as murder. (Spoiler: it’s punishing people for what they believe is immoral behavior.)

Prosecuting women for getting abortions and sentencing them to death is an outrageous proposal. (And Georgia knows that—they’re just trying to overturn Roe v. Wade.) Have you had a miscarriage? Could you imagine the burden of proof you would be subjected to to prove that you didn’t intentionally cause it? Would you be arrested and have to bail out while the investigation took place? Would you have to take state-mandated pregnancy tests every month and be under a doctors care for all of your baby making years? (Again, for people who believe the government should be minimally involved, there are some interesting implications.)

It is estimated that nearly 1 in 4 women will have had an abortion by the age of 45. So let’s keep this in mind as we continue. How many women do you know personally in your life? Now imagine 1 out of every 4 that you’re talking to have had abortions. Are your conversations with women seasoned with grace and compassion or are you focused on labeling them “baby killers” and making it harder for them to receive much needed medical care?

The problem with believing that fetuses have souls (and the same rights as babies) is (1) that was never a biblical teaching, (2) there’s no scientific or biblical evidence for that, (3) the right to life becomes a right to being born, which then logically becomes a right to forced birth, which then logically becomes a right to forced sterilization.

Who gets to make decisions about who is born and to whom they’re born? I can see states coming back and saying, “Hey, we’ve got too many babies that we can’t support with welfare. Let’s go ahead and sterilize people who are on government assistance.” Or, “You know, our society can’t support kids with disabilities or genetic conditions, so let’s sterilize anyone who has a disability or medical condition.”  Does that sound far-fetched? Why? It’s in line with the same reasoning that calls for the death penalty.

I can show statistics that show legalizing abortion and providing access to good social services (free or affordable medical care, housing, livable wages, and sex education) actually *reduces* the number of abortions.

And this is why I think for most anti-abortion people, it’s not really about murdering babies as much as it is about punishing those deemed “immoral.”

Think about it this way. Why is there such a stigma around teen pregnancy? If abortions are evil and unwanted, those advocating for banning abortions would totally surround pregnant teen mothers with celebration and life and support because she has a LIFE in her. They would house and clothe and feed her because they’d be doing all that for the unborn soul in her body. And if abortions are evil and murder, then anti-abortion people would be shouting from the rooftops, demanding free healthcare and sex education and affordable housing because that has been proven to stop murder. If it’s about murder, then prevention would be loved and embraced.

If it’s about punishment, then social services would be refused, women would be left alone once the baby was born, and there would be 442,995 children left alone in foster care. But surely, it’s not about punishment?

Personally, my own beliefs about souls correlate with when fetuses reach the age of consciousness or viability (6 months gestation). Abortions don’t happen past 6 months—EXCEPT for a medical reason or social barrier (THIS is important right here.) They just don’t. Don’t let people tell you that women are choosing to kill their babies because they don’t want the hassle. Guys. It’s not happening. And if you think it is—show me. Show me the evidence. Because abortions after 6 months constitute only 1% of the population and happen when women are experiencing domestic violence, abject poverty, substance abuse, or mental health issues.

(Wouldn’t it make more sense to address the violence and poverty?)

One thing I learned in school was “never take something away without having something to replace it.”

If you are anti-abortion, HOW will you impact society to make abortion unnecessary? What societal (NOT personal) changes are you proposing and advocating for that will directly affect these women seeking abortions after 6 months?

Also, I don’t ascribe to the view that you have to care about everything equally all the time, but you cannot (as hard as you try), call yourself pro-life and support a million policies and laws that lead to the death of thousands of children and adults. Please have a consistent life ethic.

(Also, do not come at me with arguments about the private sector and churches handling all these problems. If they aren’t doing it now, why do you think they’ll do it when abortions are outlawed. Over 400,000 children in foster care and how many churches could at least pay for their food and clothes and housing while they’re waiting for families? It’s happening right now. You are not pro-life if you have no concern for lives different than yours. You are pro-punishment.)

I can talk for hours about bodily autonomy and things like forced organ donation (spoiler alert: we don’t do that, even when another life is on the line) or the mortality rate of birthing mothers (not fun to look at).

But the most important thing I want to say is this—quit shaming women and start valuing them. Punishment is not a value that people should hold—especially Christian people, who make up a large portion of anti-abortion advocates.

Thank you for listening. Please start with compassion in all you do...and then let’s start seeing the dignity of all.

Reset

picture of a pink light with words that spell "and breathe"


I do this every now and then. My brain takes on all the things and wants to do it all and starts with good intentions, but gets overwhelmed. I'm pressing a reset on my blog--haven't written on here in a year and half! Since I love the name, and I'm not a huge fan of deleting past work* (even though it can be embarrassing as I grow and change and progress in my language and beliefs), I'm going to keep this platform and be more intentional about posting on it. 

So here's to fresh starts.

*I have recently reverted my old posts to drafts, but if there is something you want to read that you saw on here, let me know and I'll send it to you. 

The Four Ideologies of Abortion

TW: Abortion I can’t turn off comments on individual posts, so I’m asking you to be respectful of my page. Remember, social media consum...